Peanut ****** *****, I'm not a fan of Ben & Jerry's ice cream-too complicated, & I don't mean politically, lol. I mean like the flavors have to have a ton of stuff in them. Suppose you want just a classic flavor, like vanilla or cookies & cream or something simple like that. With Ben & Jerry's, you're out of luck. I mean yeah, they have fro-yo that comes in more simple flavors, but suppose you don't want fro-yo. I was once in the mood for a milkshake,& the only place around was a Ben & Jerry's. Of course you can make a shake out of any flavor you want, but IMO, their flavors are just not what you would use for a milkshake.
I guess I'd go with the chocolate/peanut ******, it's the least complicated of the flavors,& I like chocolate & peanut ****** together. But really, I'd take Breyer's over Ben & Jerry's any day.